August 22, 2024

The Obamas Speak

Former U.S. President Barack Obama and his wife Michelle Obama delivered a one-two punch at the Democratic National Convention on Tuesday night, urging Americans to back Kamala Harris in her 11th-hour presidential bid against Republican Donald Trump.” Reuters

See past issues

From the Left

The left praises the Obamas’ speeches, arguing that they were effective against Trump.

“Part of the Obamas’ job here, it became quickly obvious, was to go on the attack against Trump, who is famously easily triggered by these two. Michelle wasn’t afraid to approach that job from the vantage of race: ‘His limited, narrow view of the world made him feel threatened by the existence of two hardworking, highly educated, successful people who happen to be Black,’ she said. Few others could carry a tough, true message like this and still seem calm, temperate, almost sweet.”

Vinson Cunningham, New Yorker

“In her remarks, Obama sought to draw a clear contrast between Harris and Donald Trump, calling the vice-president one of the ‘most dignified’ people to seek the presidency. ‘Kamala has shown her allegiance to this nation. Not by spewing anger and bitterness, but by living a life of service, and always pushing the doors of opportunity open to others,’ she said.”

Nia Prater, New York Magazine

“Harris, she said, approaches the task from a mindset that Trump’s own background and nature ensure he never can. Harris ‘understands that most of us will never be afforded the grace of failing forward’ and ‘will never benefit from the affirmative action of generational wealth.’ Most Americans won’t get a ‘second, third, or fourth chance’ if they ‘bankrupt a business or choke in a crisis.’”

Jim Newell, Slate

“‘Kamala and Tim understand that when everybody gets a fair shot, we are all better off,’ [Barack Obama] said. ‘Just like we can keep our streets safe while also building trust between law enforcement and the communities they serve and eliminating bias that will make it better for everybody.’ He presented this as a contrast to Trump’s zero-sum vision, which implies that we can only help ourselves at the expense of others…

“Toward the end of his speech, Obama aimed an argument squarely at his own party… ‘We start thinking that the only way to win is to scold and shame and out-yell the other side,’ Obama said, ‘And after a while, regular folks just tune out, or they don’t bother to vote.’…

“Obama argues that, despite Trump’s ugliness, most Americans are still decent and good. If you appeal to them in a smart and empathetic way, they will recognize their commonalities.”

Jonathan Chait, New York Magazine

From the Right

The right is critical of the Obamas’ speeches, arguing that the calls for decency were misleading.

The right is critical of the Obamas’ speeches, arguing that the calls for decency were misleading.

“Obama spent a good chunk of the speech arguing for mutual understanding among Americans, but he framed this apparent plea for empathy as condescendingly as he talked about his former vice president. ‘If a parent or grandparent occasionally says something that makes us cringe, we don’t automatically assume they’re bad people,’ Obama said. ‘We recognize that the world is moving fast, that they need time and maybe a little encouragement to catch up.’…

“One can make certain inferences here: If you dissent from the Democratic agenda—including its endorsement of the trans agenda, climate change hysteria, and near-religious fervor for unrestricted abortion… Obama is not saying that he actually will tolerate your viewpoint. He is simply saying he will be patient with you until you come around to his.”

Peter Tonguette, American Conservative

“Perhaps the most confusing aspect of the night was Obama’s call for a return to decency. The former president, in fact, argued that America needed ‘a new chapter, a better story,’ even though his own vice president, Joe Biden, has been in office for nearly four years. Come to think of it, Kamala Harris has also been in office for nearly four years. What has either done to make our politics less divisive or our lives more joyful?”

David Harsanyi, New York Post

“It’s still Obama’s party — not in the sense that Obama is the shadow president, pulling the strings of the Biden administration, but clearly he is still the center of gravity… For Democrats of a certain age, election night 2008 was the happiest moment of their political lives. (The promise of hope and change on that night was better than the inevitable compromises and disappointments in the eight years of reality that followed.)…

“Obama changed campaigning for president, and changed Americans’ expectations of what a president ought to be. He could be professorial — some called him aloof — but he could also talk NCAA picks on ESPN, or make goofy videos with a selfie stick to tout his ill-fated healthcare.gov website. Obama was a full-spectrum pop culture celebrity — and Harris, coconut memes and all, is following in those footsteps.”

Jim Geraghty, Washington Post