December 11, 2024

Brian Thompson’s Murder

“A 26-year-old man has been charged with murder over last week's fatal shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in New York City. Luigi Mangione was taken into custody at a McDonald's in the town of Altoona, Pennsylvania, on Monday after a customer at the fast-food outlet recognised him. An Ivy League graduate from a prominent Maryland family, he was found in possession of a gun and a handwritten document that expressed ‘ill will’ towards corporate America, according to police.” BBC

“[Last] Wednesday's shocking murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson unleashed a wave of social media-fueled rage against health insurers, with posters lashing out over coverage denials and other business practices.” Axios

See past issues

From the Left

The left generally argues that many people are justifiably upset about health insurance companies.

“[A September 2023 survey] found that nearly one in five insured adults had a claim turned down by insurers in the US over the 12 months prior. UnitedHealthcare, in particular, has reportedly used computer algorithms to automatically deny rehab care to vulnerable seniors in Medicare Advantage plans…

“Meanwhile, the company’s revenue ballooned to the tune of $372 billion last year. Thompson himself took home $10.2 million… However insensitive, these reactions cut to an anger, shared by many Americans, at the state of the health-insurance industry.”

Jon Skolnik and Caitlin Dewey, Vanity Fair

“Many people seem to think Thompson got what he deserved. The glee we’re seeing doesn’t just stem from animosity towards insurance companies, but anger towards an unfair system in which the elite rarely seem to face any consequences for their actions. The banks that caused the 2008 financial crisis got bailed out while regular people lost their homes. The key executives behind the opioid crisis may never see a jail cell…

“To be clear: I am not in any way condoning Thompson’s murder or endorsing vigilantes shooting CEOs on the street. Murdering anyone is quite clearly wrong. But please spare me the pearl-clutching.”

Arwa Mahdawi, The Guardian

“What is particularly stunning about all this is that one of the core arguments used against putting in place a single-payer health care system like Medicare for All in the United States — by politicians, political commentators, corporate flacks — is that people simply love their private health insurance too much. These comments show this is blatantly untrue.”

Branko Marcetic, Jacobin Magazine

“I found myself wincing at the tone of the messages rolling in on my various group threads and social media sites… My compass on these things is always how I’d want my daughter to hear me react in such a moment. Would I want her to think it’s okay to dance on the grave of someone whose sons are now fatherless?…

“I also worry that the rage is causing more people to gravitate toward ideas that ultimately are dangerous. There seems to be a growing attitude that real change can only come by burning it all down. Or that we need to be open to extreme approaches to fixing our system — even if they involve sacrificing bedrock tenets of public health. One needs only look at the positive caveats many suddenly seem to be finding in the incoming administration’s picks to lead the nation’s top public health agencies as a guide.”

Lisa Jarvis, Bloomberg

From the Right

The right condemns Mangione and criticizes those expressing sympathy for him.

The right condemns Mangione and criticizes those expressing sympathy for him.

“If you’re really interested in aiding the uninsured, there are a lot of ways to help… You can donate money and encourage others to donate to defray operating costs. You can volunteer. You can donate supplies. Every last clinic would welcome the assistance in any form. But this guy didn’t do anything like that. Instead, he tracked the movements of the top official in the biggest health-insurance company in the country and shot him in the back…

“No, from everything we know so far, Luigi Mangione just wanted to kill somebody. He’s no folk hero or revolutionary, and he’s not ‘John Wick-meets-Erin Brockovich.’ He’s just another angry, screwed-up young man who wanted to learn what it felt like to take another man’s life, who didn’t even have the courage to look his victim in the face before he pulled the trigger.”

Jim Geraghty, National Review

“People want a healthcare system that works well, not a bunch of dead CEOs. And so far, every time the government has intervened in health insurance markets they have made things more expensive, not less. Back when I was buying my health insurance in 2010, I had good coverage for about $5k a year, including deductibles. When Obamacare kicked in it jumped to about $22k a year, including deductibles…

“I'm not defending United Healthcare's business practices; I'm defending solving problems through civilization. This means understanding how things work, why they work as they do, what the costs and benefits of changes are, and how to deal with limited resources…

“Shooting people is not going to make things better. It is the adult version of a temper tantrum, only with dead bodies. See the French Revolution if you want to know how successfully a strategy of killing the rich solves problems.”

David Strom, Hot Air

“We see a common derangement in the assassin and his online fans: the idea that the US health insurance industry is willfully evil, which makes violence against its execs somehow rational. Lord knows, health care financing in this country can be a bewildering, maddening mess. But the left’s obsession with a government takeover as the cure for all ills, and its demonizing of those who disagree, is nothing but dim-witted arrogance…

“Fact is, health insurance in the country is entangled by a host of government-imposed costs and other mandates. And socialized medical systems like Britain’s and Canada’s require people to wait months to get specialist care or basic tests like MRIs that most Americans get within days. Residents of those countries who can afford it routinely turn to the private sector. There’s no such thing as infinite ‘free’ care.”

Editorial Board, New York Post